State Farm® Insurance Agent Josh Carter

"Great people!"

"I've had a great experience working with Josh Carter and his team at State Farm. While they can't control the rising cost of insurance, they've always taken the time to explain why rates change and what factors are affecting my policies. I truly appreciate their honesty, transparency, and willingness to answer my questions so I can make informed decisions.

What really sets Josh and his team apart is their personable, caring approach. They treat you like a valued client, not just another policy number, and they're always responsive and willing to help. I highly recommend Josh Carter and his State Farm office to anyone looking for knowledgeable, trustworthy insurance professionals."

""Josh and his team are absolutely top notch. From day-to-day service and communication to handling a real claim situation — we hit a deer last October — Josh, Jill, Amanda, and the rest of the team were fantastic every step of the way. But what really sets them apart is how much they invest in the local community. They've shown up for our family in ways that go well beyond insurance, and that means a lot. You never really know how good your agent is until you actually need them, and the Josh Carter Agency passed that test with flying colors. Highly recommend!""

"I was paying around $230 to $240 with Progressive and got tired of rates going up for no reason—even after 7 or 8 years with them at their top tier. You don’t get a real rep with them. Just someone juggling a thousand accounts, answering from home with dogs barking in the background. It felt disconnected.

Then I reached out to State Farm. Jack from Josh Carter’s office followed up fast, matched my current coverage, and actually sat down with me in person. We talked through not just auto insurance, but life and disability too. It was an honest, focused conversation about how to really protect myself.

The best part? State Farm is local. I’m not getting hit with rate hikes because of disasters in other states. I’m dealing with people here, who know the area, and who care about what I need.

Big thanks to Jack. He was professional, personable, and easy to talk to. Kept eye contact, listened, and was sharp through the whole thing. Appreciate the way he handled everything, felt more like a partner than a salesman."

"They are always there when you need them! No matter if it's the weekend, they manage to help you out. They always respond on time and meet your needs—even adding coverage for special cases, if necessary."

"Josh and his team have been an absolute pleasure to work with. Megan was extremely helpful and everything was made very easy for us to get insured. Highly recommended working with them for your insurance needs too!"

"Let’s start by saying the boss Always buys lunch! Forgive our delay on this review as we just returned from our road trip to New England, knowing we were in Good Hands all the way. Our State Farm review must include Craig Te Ronde and His crew. Craig was my co worker in the Neenah public schools and we became State Farm customers when Craig stepped out on his own. He rescued us from high rates on fast cars.
Through these many years our State Farm reps have offered seamless quality service in so many ways.
We decided to give our 5 star review at this moment to….Diana Hamstra!

Best regards to Josh."

"We were looking to switch from our old insurance company as we had outdated policies and our original agent had left the industry. We met with Josh and he provided a detailed review of our current policies and how State Farm could improve our coverage. Based on Josh's advice, we now feel adequately covered for the costs. Josh is knowledgeable to work with and flexible in scheduling to meet our needs. He understood what we were looking for and answered all of our questions."

"Josh Carter is an amazing supporter of NHS Baseball! The Booster Club wants to THANK JOSH for his donations to help make Alumni Day a success today! A great example of COMMUNITY!!! ⚾️🚀"

"Josh has been a great agent for us. He makes sure our coverage is what we need each year. We had a claim a few years ago and Josh was awesome through the whole process.

Not only is he a great agent he gives back to the community. He's a big sponsor if high school and youth sports in Neenah.

I would recommend Josh Carter for anyone looking for an insurance agent."

"Thank you so much for your continued support of Neenah High school baseball! We appreciate all you do for our program from game day sponsorships, alumni day and golf outings! We appreciate you!"

"Great people"

"Wow! Diana Hamstra went above and beyond in helping me with my account. She not only took care of the issue, but called me back and texted as a follow-up. Thank you, Diana for the top-notch service!"

"Josh and his staff were great to work with. Not only did they save us money for our insurance needs, but their customer service is top-notch. I will definitely be recommending them to my friends and family."

"They have always been super friendly and helpful when I need something for my home or my vehicle! Would highly recommend them any day of the week!"

"Always helpful when I call or text and willing to answer questions! Makes it easy to manage my insurance."

"Josh and his team are always helpful, friendly and knowledgeable. They are quick to respond and willing to listen. Great service every time!"

"jill was magnificent to work with. Handled my problem expeditiously. Great lady"

"Amazing people to work with. Made insuring motorcycle and other vehicles very easy."

"Diana was very helpful in a recent phone conversation. She recommended changing a policy to be paid quarterly instead of a yearly payment, and that eased my anxiety about paying a larger, lump sum."

"Very easy to work with and extremely efficient in what they do. Switching to Josh and his team was a no brainer based on the level of service and reasonable costs. They made it as easy as humanly possible for me to make the switch. I would highly recommend giving them a call to have them review your policies."

"When it comes to insurance, relying on Josh Carter and his team at State Farm Insurance has made my life easier. They are always a phone call or email away...whether for something big (sump pump failure) or something small (policy change). I have been especially fortunate to work closely with Diana Hamstra. She is always courteous and efficient. Keep up the great work!"

"They are so personable. They also do whatever they can to keep me covered with what I can afford. No pressure!!💕"

"I started with Josh Carter in 2015 with a life insurance. He was thorough explaining life insurance policies and assisting me in select the policy that would work best for both my needs and finances.
Last year, I was realizing that my car insurance policies cost were increasing. I decided to contact Josh Carter office to assist me in reviewing my car insurance needs. I worked with Amanda she was so knowledgeable with car insurance policies then also assisted with switching my home owners insurance. She was able clearly explain all aspects of my insurance policies line by line and answer all my questions! Switching to State Farm using Josh Cater’s was a significant savings with my car insurance policies!!
Last year we had an auto claim that was handled quickly and efficiently! Whenever we had questions about the claim, I contacted Josh Carter’s office and they were answered in a timely manner!
This year, Amanda contacted me via email to do a yearly review of all my insurance policies, car, home policy, umbrella policy and life insurance before the renewal date. I found this so helpful and there were actually a few changes we addressed.
I feel taken care of by Josh Cater’s office, especially Amanda and all the staff that have assisted me the auto claim and all my other insurance policies. I would highly recommend them!!!"

"It was such a pleasure working with Meghan Kopplin! She walked us through all of our policies in a way that was easy to understand and ended up getting us more coverage while actually saving us money, which was a huge win. We really appreciated her knowledge and follow-through throughout the whole process. I’d definitely recommend Meghan and the team at Josh Carter State Farm. Thanks for making everything so easy!"